Reply Brief﻿

Reply Brief

8/22/2015

Scott’s Reply Brief has been filed with the State and is available for reading at the following link:

Reply Brief

This is the third of three documents that needed to be filed with the Supreme Court of the State of California for Scott’s appeal. The next step is oral arguments. Scott’s appellate attorney, Cliff Gardner, and an opposing attorney from the State Attorney General’s office will be called before the Supreme Court of the State of California for an hour or two of oral arguments. This day will most likely occur in two to three years. Once the Court hears oral arguments, they will hand down a decision on Scott’s appeal within 90 days.

The filing of this third document also starts a six month countdown for Scott’s habeas petition. This is a separate court filing where Scott’s attorneys bring forth new evidence and information that was not heard in court. The deadline for the habeas petition to be filed is January 23, 2016.

The courts could overturn Scott’s conviction based on the information in either one of these filings.

60 Comments

Elle

9/16/2015 10:42:48 am

I have always thought he was innocent. I remember this case like it was yesterday. I am up in Canada and still follow as much as I can. My prayers go out to you and your family xo

Wendy Schutze

1/21/2016 05:56:55 am

Hope they kill him soon, would be great to weigh him down with an anchor and watch him drown, hopefully when he gets to hell he will have to suffer what he did to Lacey and Connor for eternity

Landon brando

6/9/2016 12:48:18 pm

What the hell is a matter with you?
Stop making outrageous comments about Scott.
Your totally insane.
Scott is INNOCENT

Grow up.
Your insane

J. Smith

4/27/2017 11:29:13 am

me, too. He's rotting away in his cell. Good enough for me.

alicia

5/9/2017 12:54:03 pm

While we all have different views on this case, I do believe its obvious that this is a site geared towards those with views pertaining to Scott's innocence. So it is immature and thoughtless to come and post replies such as this. There are entire sites dedicated to people who share your feelings. Please spare the family and express them there. Thank you.

Tera

9/5/2017 09:43:20 pm

Wendy I agree with you 100% these people that believe he's innocent are probably religious fanatics that just simply don't believe in the death penalty which I hope he eventually gets whether someone does it to him or it just happens Amber his girlfriend said he did it and only he admitted it to her for Lacey and the baby there was no one else on earth that wanted her dad he didn't want to pay child support he didn't want to pay alimony any have a new hot blonde

Liz

9/10/2017 03:31:45 pm

Amen

Trish

9/16/2017 12:43:37 pm

Questions -
1. How does someone predict that their pregnant wife will be "lost" prior to them disappearing?
2. How do their bodies float to the surface in the same area that Scott was fishing?
3. Who doesn't stay home to help their pregnant, tired wife with preparing Christmas Brunch? if he really loves her?

The truth can be found in the factual evidence provided at trial. The other "Laci" sightings were of another 8 month pregnant woman with a Labrador Retriever who resembled Laci. There is a excellent book, " A Deadly Game" by Catherine Crier that provides the factual evidence offered in Court.

It costs the taxpayers more money $ to put him to death than it would a life sentence. Scott is Guilty and deserves the punishment determined by the jury.

Ellen

5/6/2018 10:29:17 am

First off, do not simply assume that everyone who believes that Scott Peterson might be innocent are "religious fanatics", as I am 38 and have not been religious in any way a day in my life. I am anti-death penalty, to be fair, but that has nothing at all to do with why I believe that there is a high probability that Scott had nothing to do with his wife's disappearance/murder. A TOTAL LACK OF ANY PHYSICAL EVIDENCE THAT SCOTT HAD ANYTHING TO DO WITH IT, COMBINED WITH VERY LITTLE CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE THAT HE HAD ANYTHING TO DO WITH EITHER, THESE ARE THE REASONS WHY I BELIEVE THAT HE SHOULD HAVE NEVER BEEN CONVICTED OF 1ST DEGREE MURDER...I truly believe that if the local and national media hadn't done what they did, acted the way that they did, and if the media and the police/DA had not used and exploited Amber Frey and Scott's affair with her during his wife's pregnancy, that he would have never been convicted by the jury at all...However, another huge factor in his jury conviction was their pre-conceived notions about Scott and his behavior while Laci was pregnant...As one female juror who was an alternate and who was called to the jury late in deliberations put it as she first walked into the jury deliberation room, "HE KILLED THE LITTLE MAN, LET'S FIND HIM GUILTY AND GET THIS OVER WITH"...Really?

The bottom-line to this entire case is that we as a country are far too anxious and willing to convict a person and put them in prison for the rest of their life or execute them without ANY physical and/or circumstantial evidence that they did it or had anything to do with it. And the fact that Scott was a slime-ball of a husband who had an affair with another woman while his wife was pregnant with his child IS NOT EVIDENCE OF HIS GUILT IN LACI'S DISAPPEARANCE OR MURDER! It's just not evidence. NOR ARE OUR OWN PERCEPTIONS OF THE DEFENDANT'S FACIAL EXPRESSIONS OR OUR OWN PERCEPTIONS OF HIS "LACK OF EMOTION" EVIDENCE OF HIS GUILT! It's just not evidence! You don't have to like Scott Peterson or any other lying, cheating defendant who is on trial, he wasn't a good person, no doubt about that. He was a selfish man/husband who made selfish choices and didn't give a damn about his marriage...okay, that makes Scott Peterson and thousands of other married people...A murderer does that not make!

11 different people saw Laci walking her dog the morning of 12/24 around her neighborhood, long after Scott was proven to have left his house and be far away from his home, as verified by cell phone tower pings, his work computer history, his boat launch receipt and the multiple people who saw him trolling out of the Berkeley Marina in his EMPTY boat, and his cell phone pings on his way home later that afternoon. The Modesto PD ignored all 11 of these witnesses who saw and positively identified Laci walking her dog that morning, they ignored the evidence of the house directly across the street being broken into that morning, even trying to change the date of the break-in to 2 days later when it was actually early on the morning of 12/24, and they ignored multiple witnesses to the men standing outside of the house across the street next to a white van. They ignored ALL EVIDENCE OF SCOTT'S INNOCENCE, and as soon as they knew that Amber Frey existed they determined that Scott must have been guilty, case closed. THIS IS NOT HOW OUR JUSTICE SYSTEM IS SUPPOSED TO WORK PEOPLE.

****I could just as easily say that it's you people who was to see Scott suffer and die without there being one shred of physical evidence and very little to no circumstantial evidence that he had anything at all to do with Laci's disappearance who are the "Religious Fanatics" who believe in "An eye for an eye", or who are perfectly happy and feel fine about sentencing a person to death on your "gut feelings" and because Scott was a cheating husband who lied to everyone about having an affair.

HOW CAN ANYONE BE OKAY PUTTING ANOTHER HUMAN BEING TO DEATH OR TAKING THE REST OF THEIR LIFE AWAY FROM THEM WHEN THERE'S ZERO PHYSICAL EVIDENCE THAT HE HAD ANYTHING TO DO WITH IT, AND TONS OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE THAT HE DIDN'T HAVE A THING TO DO WITH IT AT ALL? Because he's a cheating, lying, slime-ball husband he should be convicted of a murder that someone else got away with, and then executed? THIS IS WHY WE IN THE UNITED STATES NEED TO HAVE PROFESSIONAL JURORS WHO UNDERSTAND THE DEFINITION OF "REASONABLE DOUBT', BECAUSE IF THERE WASN'T REASONABLE DOUBT IN THIS CASE THEN I DON'T KNOW WHAT CASE WOULD HAVE ANY AT ALL...And jurors who don't listen to mainstream-media prosecutors who assume everyone is guilty until proven innocent, such as Nancy Grace, who would execute or lock every person even arrested for murder away for life immediately, without a trial...

Do your own research, AND WHEN I SAY "RESEARCH" I DON'T MEAN WATCHING THE NEWS, THE MEDIA, WATCHING DOCUMENTARIES AND SUCH, I MEAN READ THE POLICE REPORTS, THE POLICE INVESTIGATION FILES, AND THE ENTIRE CASE-FIL

Tera

8/5/2018 12:20:55 pm

Wendy I agree with you! The pain his wife and child suffered was horrific- the loss of what could have been for Lacy’s parents becoming grandparents.
Amber under oath proved Scott was guilty! How naive some of these people are to think anyone but Scott has motive is beyond my comprehension- dumbfounded!

Landon

6/1/2016 08:56:43 pm

I totally agree Scott was a scape goat to close out a high profile case and calm down the community. God bless you Scott.

annie

6/9/2016 01:29:50 pm

He is innocent they will figure it out!!

Adam

11/13/2016 08:42:27 pm

He is guilty. I can't believe you still think he is innocent. He killed is wife and UNBORN SON HE DESERVES TO DIE DIE DIE

Sharon

8/24/2017 08:28:17 pm

He is guily as hell

Tera

9/5/2017 09:41:17 pm

He's about as innocent as O.J. Simpson he didn't want the baby he was cheating on his wife and he admitted to the girlfriend she testified against him how could anyone think otherwise he's guilty

Sheri

9/19/2015 06:01:59 am

I, too, have followed this case from the beginning and I, like Elle follow as much as I can. I live in CA. I think of Scott often. My prayers and heart go out to him and the family. I can't wrap my head around what has happened and how injustice has overtaken public opinion. It's scary scary stuff at best. People can't seem to realize that "it could happen to you too." Love to you all.

Shelley Moss

9/19/2015 10:56:26 pm

I wholeheartedly believe the conviction will be overturned. Stay strong Scott. There are people who believe in you.

Klarissa Diaz link

10/11/2017 02:37:41 pm

There is nothing to believe in besides murder. Do you not see the facts? He killed Laci and he is going to die in 2021. Good luck getting his conviction overturned before he gets put to death!

Brandy

9/30/2015 10:31:15 pm

I remember this case like it was yesterday. Scott was doomed from the very beginning. He was presumed guilty, not innocent. I find it disgusting what the media did to this poor man. I can't believe how unfairly things unfolded. Not only did his lose his wife and baby, but his freedom and life was taken. I pray for Scott and his family everyday. I hope that he can get a impartial, fair trial.

annie

11/8/2015 08:43:35 pm

Don't ever give up ... for any one that truly followed the trial based on evidence we know Scott is innocent!

Ana Adame link

12/2/2015 11:24:20 am

All of you are fools for believing this animals is innocent! Show the real comments, not just the good ones, which by the way are not many!!! Die in prison Scott!

Joanna

5/28/2016 12:33:29 am

Why don't you die -moronic version of american society,there wasnt never any evidence that backed the verdict condemning Scott so you people learn first how to investigate instead of believing whatever media told you to believe without using your own mind as its too much to ask of you!Pathetic

Liz

9/10/2017 03:42:24 pm

I will pray for all of you. I guess he should've had a better defense going into the trial. If you're stating all the snow what's wrong with his attorney should he be called out on a poor job? I'm sorry innocent people who are given the death penalty do not react the way Scott did. He may have been nervous about them pointing this case in his direction however he said nothing to Amber about any of this. if that was my spouse and we were about to have a child and she was missing I would be honest because that's what counts in this case his honesty. Tell her the truth because his name is about to be blown all over the media. He might be embarrassed telling her but what's more important here the truth or carrying on an affair with a woman who's about to everything from the news. I'm sorry I've gotten everything you have to offer and I'm sorry I just don't buy it in at the prosecution said that at the end of the case or the end of the trial that needs to be fired and the dra i'm sorry I've gone everything you have to offer. Reading with the prosecution said, the jury should've come back with a different verdict done it could've even been a mistrial at least. The Jury member who said he was being threatened I don't care who you are you stand up for what you believe in and you never back down.. You report to the judge what's going on you don't wait till now. I wish you luck

Sharon

8/24/2017 08:29:53 pm

I agree with you due in prison

Lisa Diaz

12/2/2015 12:23:41 pm

The reason that Scott traveled to San Francisco Bay on Christmas Eve to "fish" was because, knowing the Modesto farm area as you say "like the back of his hand", he knew that the bodies would eventually be discovered if he buried Laci on land.

I'm sorry that you people can't accept the truth about what happened. Your hearts are broken - I understand. My mother was murdered by her husband when she was 21. None of our hearts ever healed from it. But Scott is 100% guilty. That is a FACT.

Laney

2/28/2017 12:56:05 pm

Lisa Diaz, I am very sorry for your loss. What a terrible tragedy. I too am a domestic violence survivor. I know first hand what that pain feels like. I understand your hurt. But you must understand that we will never really know if Scott did it or not, because the police did not provide enough physical evidence to convict him. Just because he cheated and lied does not make him a murderer. You need a weapon, DNA or some kind of physical evidence to put make someone the perpetrator. Everything that was provided was only circumstantial. You may not like the guy and think he is has horrible character or even a sociopath. It doesn't matter, because in america everyone has a right to a fair and un-prejudice trial. You can not condemn someone to die without the proper evidence. The State and police did not provide this in a court of law. And If they can not provide it, then it becomes an unsolved case. Period. I know that thought is truly sad, but it has to be fair. There can not be any reasonable doubt and this case had too much reasonable doubt and prejudice to convict Scott of the crime. Without these safe guards we all should be very scared if God forbid we are ever accused of something. We all have a right to due process for a reason. It's not to protect criminals, it is to protect innocent people. It is even for people that you don't care for their character. They may be horrible character but it doesn't make them a murderer. As citizens whom may be asked to sit on a jury someday, we have a responsibility to not let our emotions ruin another persons right to justice. It is "innocent until prove guilty". They did not prove he was guilty. They just didn't like the guy and said he did it. There has to be physical evidence to support it. Yes, he was at the marina, but there are no witnesses to him dumping a body, DNA on the body or in his boat or house, any murder weapon. Nothing. I hope that Scott gets his appeal, and yes, he does deserve it. I hope that the police do a better job collecting evidence and this terrible crime finally gets properly solved. I want justice for Laci and Connor so very much, but I also do not feel comfortable in my heart knowing that someone is getting ready to be put to death for this crime and it was without the physical evidence to do so. That itself would be a crime. We don't put a liar and a cheat to death in this country, and that is truly the only evidence that has been shown against Scott. Good luck to all of the families. I hope you all get the justice you deserve.

Liz

9/10/2017 03:43:25 pm

I concur

Yvette Heath link

11/15/2017 09:28:42 am

They need to execute his sorry a** already. He is guilty and deserves to be punished. I am so sick of reading he never got a fair trial. He is a liar,cheater, and murderer.

Tera

8/5/2018 12:36:47 pm

Well said Yvette! I’m tired of paying for his meals- kill the murdered already!

Joseph

1/26/2016 07:08:39 am

You people are delusional! Peterson is s text book sociopath and is EXACTLY where he needs to be. Blinded but some very small, minor details and here say. Amazing!! I only wish they would bump up his death date as he's living the good life on death row! No remote, no ability to feel consequences for his actions, manipulative, liar, cheater--text book sociopath. Folowed that case from beginning to end, he's as guilty as Ted Bundy was and same personality. Can't understand why our US government would allow this man to have a blog or 5 hours or outdoors time, unbelievable!

Lynda

3/4/2016 08:27:11 am

What a joke..... Rot in prison you murderer!

Joanna

4/3/2016 10:40:38 am

I have been following this case from the beginning and all evidence against Scott were irrelevant and circumstantial ,I think they needed so badly to make arrest that they deliver Scott on the plate and had not examined other important evidence .American justice had many loop holes and I'm glad I moved to Europe as this case it's been great failure of American constitutional rights ,just as well as Ramsey case .I hope Scott will be freed,but no money or apologises can ever recompasate for what he had gone through and real killers are still on the lose

Fred

4/10/2016 04:59:37 pm

See you at the execution! (Approver: I hope that deleting my comment briefly reminds you that a needle will one day be placed in Scottie lee's arm to deliver a purplish liquid that will unceremoniously terminate his dim life.)

Joanna

5/28/2016 12:28:44 am

Only simple minded and not intelligent people would think Scott is guilty based on non existent evidence and by buying whatever media sold them.I feel really sorry for them as those types are masses in America society and that's why easy to be manipulated-dream on .You so sure about Scott involvement in his wife death based on what???Whatever TV told you -joke but when O.J Simpson killed his wife and walked what have you people done???Nothing!!!!!!!Its all about money if Laci family was poor you people would probably never heard about her case like you never did about another pregnant woman who vanished few months before Laci did in the same area!!!!

Sammy

11/23/2016 02:11:38 pm

This has nothing to do with money and everything to do with media coverage....at the end of the day only Scott knows the truth because most family members are too involved emotionally to be rational about their own son culpability or innocence! It is simply a very story!

Landon

6/1/2016 08:26:28 am

I am sick to my stomach that an innocent man sits on death row and has been going through hell while he grieves the loss of his Loving wife and son. Scott was made a scape goat for the prosecution to close out this high profile murder trial. I am confident that the truth will come out it always does and the real killer is still walking the streets. Scott I love you and pray for you daily. Scott is INNOCENT end of story.

Landon

6/1/2016 08:31:10 am

SCOTT STAY STRONG
TRUST ME GOD KNOWS YOUR INNOCENT AND HE WILL NOT ONLY FREE YOU BUT KEEP YOU SAFE UNTIL YOUR CONVICTION IS OVERTURNED. I LOVE YOU BUDDY HANG IN THERE AND DON'T LISTEN TO THE NEGATIVE PEOPLE. I LOVE YOU.

Emmerson

6/1/2016 01:41:38 pm

Scott your innocent
Trust me the truth will come out.

Hang in there
Hugz

Landon brando

6/9/2016 12:50:08 pm

Scott is innocent
Leave him alone.

I love you Scott.

Boston

11/8/2016 06:03:32 am

let's not forget about Scott's girlfriend at the time and what she had to say about the things Scott told her......,,
But you all still want to feel sorry for him!?!? He's a wife killer, a baby killer and the biggest liar!

Stark

11/9/2016 05:12:08 pm

Burn in he'll Scott cut you'll never ever see HEAVEN !
All you believers are the ones that are delusional !!
Stark

gail hunter link

12/12/2016 12:18:21 pm

PEOPLE i live here near modesto and this low life killed her nobody else did it, i mean why would anybody else do want to this young gal had her whole life to spend with her baby this is very sad.so ask yourself WHY

Arabella

1/14/2017 04:29:15 pm

I have felt Scott was guilty, but something that was always in the back of my mind is how could he put Laci in the boat, motor out, dump her, without the small boat capsizing. His actions didn't help him either.

Linda

6/18/2017 11:01:40 am

A troublesome case, conviction mostly on circumstantial evidence. But still.....what is the alternate narrative? Some bum who killed her in Modesto would not have had a boat and a truck to transport the bodies all the way to San Francisco Bay! I believe this is why the jury convicted. There would have to be reasonable doubt, and what would that doubt be founded on? So sorry for his parents and family.

Paul

8/22/2017 08:34:56 pm

Yea, yea ... he's innocent ... yea, that's the ticket (in my best John Lovitz imitation)

Laura

8/25/2017 04:43:37 pm

I have spent many days and hours researching the court minutes, videos, blogs, movies, ect..
I FIRMLY believe in Scott... I believe he is Innocent! My heart hurts for him and his family as well as Lacis family. I'm so saddened by everyones tragic loss of this beautiful woman Laci and Connor. I keep Scott and all families in my prayers. I also pray for the day they set Scott free and realize the real monster that did this!!!
God Bless you all!

Melissa

8/30/2017 09:45:36 pm

I don't know how anyone in their right mind can think this guy is guilty or ever was . Because he didn't show a lot of emotion ? That does not make someone a killer . Because he didn't want to be seen on the television during the disappearance? Helloooo, we are taking about a man who's wife goes missing and from day one is being looked at , and he's having an affair . You think someone like that wants their face exposed on tv so people like amber frey can come forward and make him look even guiltier, which ding ding ding is exactly what happened . Not to mention all the countless people that saw laci that morning while Scott wasn't even around - society and media are such a joke and people I'm sorry are extremely jumpy when one thing gets said . Not one piece of evidence did they find linking Scott to a murder and they never will - cuz anyone who is smart can see he is innocent . People like Nancy grace only act the way she does because of her own life experience and what happened to her own husband - just makes me sick how disgusting people are . And the fact they find her body not far from where he was fishing - right away the whole world knew he went fishing , u think the real killer didn't purposely put that body in the bay knowing it would wash up and that even more that would make Scott look guilty ? Laci and Scott clearly did not have huge marital problems , sure the guy was a cheater , big whoop - he was a cheating asshole husband so are 75 percent of Americans .. most u just don't hear about , but the thought that he could take this woman , this beautiful women and her baby , his baby and just end their life because the media wants u to believe the motive was to be free and run off with amber frey is absolutely ridiculous and just insane . Not to mention , have u seen amber frey?? Not the best looking chic on the planet - no offense . It was a sexual thing with her , And that's all it was and I truly believe that .. and I think the only reason Scott kept contacting her even after laci went missing , was to make sure she didn't hear anything because he was afraid - and who the hell wouldn't have been ?? Those cops pinned him from day one - the media pinned him from day one - society pinned him from day one ,.i truly hope Scott that one day u can prove your innocence, and that the world will realize and wake the fk up-

Tommy

9/27/2017 09:25:21 pm

So, the real killer, kept her body until he/she found out where Scott went fishing that day. Than went to that area and dumped the body. Sorry, doesn't add up.

Melissa

8/5/2018 12:34:30 pm

I bet you think OJ was also innocent? Only Scott had motive he didn’t want to be a dad and didn’t want to pay child support so he says he’s going FISHING when his wife’s about to give birth and it’s Xmas?
Wake up seek medical help your in a fog...

Brandi

9/15/2017 11:59:32 pm

I firmly believe Scott is innocent and pray he gets a chance to prove it.

Stephanie

9/28/2017 09:51:22 pm

I believe Scott to be innocent of murder. Yes a liar & cheater but there is no evidence that he murdered his family. The timeline shows that. Other leads should have been given some effort.
No one mentions the storm that hits the bay where she was found which could have brought the bodies from anywhere. Also, the police did a huge search of the bay where he fished & found nothing! They did not even find the concrete blocks that supposedly held down her body which would still have been there to be found if they existed! I believe someone snatched her from the park & murdered her. So scary that the real killers completely getting away with such a sick crime. & so many lives have been torn apart.
Look at the facts. That is what our court system is supposed to do.
I believe a new trial, so many years later like it is now, will find him innocent because there are now plenty of people in California of juror age that have never heard of this case & can provide fair judgement. Damn the media.

Rest in peace Connor & Laci.
Hold onto hope Scott & Family.

Prepare for the truth everyone else.

Karen Sweatman

10/2/2017 12:51:47 am

I have serious doubts that Peterson is guilty, but whether he is or isn't, in this country you don't convict someone and give them the death penalty without a shred of evidence. He was having an affair while he was married to the victim. You are going to tell me that's enough to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt? Only in North Korea, my friend, not in America. We have standards here. The media shouldn't dictate who's guilty and who's not, who lives and who dies. That sets a very dangerous precedent. This entire case was a sham, there wasn't enough probable cause to even arrest Peterson. What is becoming of our justice system? No wonder so many death row inmates have been exonerated through DNA. The system is flawed.

Tera

8/5/2018 12:31:25 pm

Oh Karen I’m guessing your a Trump lover believing he’s innocent too?
Peterson changed his hair color, sat emotionless in court, Amber even knew he was guilty by telling her his wife is GONE before the public knew because he just killed her!!
Get a reality ck come down from the clouds and put down the koolaid

tracey

10/8/2017 05:13:06 pm

SERIOUSLY..IS THIS A JOKE ???
SCOTT PETERSON IS AS GUILTY AS THEY COME.YOU CAN SEE IT IN EVERY ASPECT OF HIS BODY.
JUST LIKE CASEY ANTHONY IS INNOCENT AS WELL.
THERES ALOT OF SICK PEOPLE OUT THERE AND SCOTT PETERSON IS ONE OF THEM.
WHOEVER SAID TO RESPECT THE FAMILY,THAT THIS SITE WAS PUT UP FOR PEOPLE WHO BELIEVE HES INNOCENT,YA..WELL IF YOU ARE GOING TO PUT UP A SOCIAL MEDIA SITE PERTAINING TO YOUR INNOCENCE.,YOU BETTER BE READY FOR THE BACKLASH AS WELL.DOESNT WORK THAT WAY.
HES GUILTY AND IF THERES NEW EVIDENCE THEN IT BEEN TRUMPED UP.
TOO FUNNY

Tera

8/5/2018 12:27:35 pm

Tracey
You got that right! He was so smug in court. He simply didn’t want to be a dad and his ego didn’t want to public to know he failed as a husband but great as a liar & cheater so instead of divorce he brutally murdered his wife and son- he should have been exacuted already, in a painful way.

Gillian

10/28/2017 06:28:13 am

Just been watching the most recent documentary, I lived in Georgia at the time of the disappearance and trial and truly believed he was innocent and still do more than ever there is no question he acted foolishly after they went missing and by having the affair but by no means makes him a murderer!! He was guilty before the trial and in this respect he could never get a fair trial, bring on the appeal! All the best from scotland x

Kim

12/22/2017 08:25:33 pm

All of these years I have believed he is guilty. I was hearsick for Laci's family but only kinda felt sorry for Scott's. Iam ashamed of that now. I do not know what to feel today after reading all of this. The timeline and things that are proven to be fact as he stated make me wonder. His affair with Amber Frye is not mentioned but I feel that was a defining moment for the jury. As much as I destest cheaters, this doesn't make a murderer. Maybe for anyone on the fence at that point he became the monster to hate. I just really felt her testimony was a driving force. I am now on the fence with this. I just don't know.

Tera

8/5/2018 07:00:00 pm

Just
Don’t be in the fence- he did it! What man pretends to be single with a 9 month pregnant wife especially conner was a son men boast about having a son
The married men usually screw around when their kids are older and the marriage is dull
They were just beginning - he simply didn’t want to be a Dad

Pat

1/5/2018 02:51:25 pm

I just finished watching A&E's "The Murder of Laci Peterson" series. After seeing evidence that was ignored and/or excluded by the police, and misrepresented (or outright wrong) in the prosecution's case, I believe Scott is innocent. God Bless the efforts of the SPA group in continuing the fight for Scott.

Tera

8/5/2018 08:28:10 pm

After reading all the comments Trish said it best- I would 💯 % agree and that is why he is in fact GUILTY needs to be sentenced ASAP to hell not heaven where his wife and son are.

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.

Reply Brief

Leave a Reply.

Archives

Categories

Reply Brief﻿

Leave a Reply.

Archives

Categories

Reply Brief